Skip to content
Security FilmGuide

How to compare security film proposals line by line

Two quotes for 'security film' can describe completely different projects. Use this checklist to make them comparable.

By Shore Tint & More editorial team · · 6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Normalize every proposal to the same opening list before comparing totals.
  • Name the exact film product and attachment method; 'or equal' needs defining.
  • Ask which tested assembly any performance claim relies on.
  • Read exclusions and warranty terms as carefully as price.

Step 1: normalize the scope

Make a single opening schedule — location, glass size, quantity, glass type if known — and ask every bidder to price against it. If one proposal omits doors or sidelites, totals are not comparable. Our project brief tool produces a starting checklist you can share.

Step 2: the comparison checklist

ItemWhat to look for
FilmManufacturer, exact product name, construction (PET or polyurethane), data sheet revision
GlassHas eligibility been checked against manufacturer guidelines for each glass type and size?
FrameCondition noted; any repairs needed before attachment
AttachmentProduct, which edges, bead or profile size, door details
Tested assemblyWhich test supports any claim, and does it match this film + attachment + glass?
CureFilm and sealant cure times; when the system can be relied on
InstallationRemoval of existing film, access, hours, protection of interiors
WarrantyWho issues it, what it covers (film, labor, glass), registration steps
ExclusionsGlass breakage during install, frame repair, after-hours premiums

Step 3: test the claims

If a proposal attaches a performance number to a product, ask for the source document. Manufacturer data sheets are careful about wording: the Ultra S800 technical specifications, for example, frames the film as helping retain fragments and delay entry, not stopping intruders. A proposal that promises more than the manufacturer does is a warning sign. To check the report behind a claim, use how to read a security film test report.

Watch for unit confusion too. 3M lists S2400 at 25 mils with adhesive (S2400 data sheet). Comparing a "with adhesive" figure against a "nominal film" figure from another product is apples to oranges.

Want a proposal written against this checklist?

Shore's assessments produce a scope that names the film, attachment and documentation.

Request an assessment →

Step 4: warranty and the dealer chain

Manufacturer warranties typically depend on proper product selection and installation by a qualified installer, and some applications have specific requirements in 3M's installation guidelines. Ask who registers the warranty and get the terms in writing; don't assume a universal lifetime guarantee.

A quote-review worksheet

Put each proposal into the same rows before comparing totals. This is an editorial review tool, not a legal or procurement mandate; adapt it to your own rules.

Quote-review worksheet, one column per proposal (editorial planning aid)
RowWhat to fill in
Opening and roomInternal opening code and room; quantity of identical openings
Glass, each plyType and thickness of each lite and any laminate — not the insulating-unit total
Frame and install sideFrame material and condition; interior or exterior film side
Exact film and systemProduct code and revision; any treatment or attachment product
Objective and evidenceIntended objective and the matching manufacturer report or document
Film quantity basisSquare feet, opening count and dimensions; net glass vs. minimum billing
Attachment, where specifiedExact system and sides; linear feet priced separately or clearly included
Glass or frame workReplacement, removal, prep — or stated as excluded
Site conditionsLifts, access, protection, work hours, taxes, exclusions
CloseoutDocuments, any mockup, aftercare, handover, warranty registration, follow-up contact

Two proposals with equal square footage can carry very different edge lengths: many small lites have far more perimeter than a few large ones, so attachment cost is not proportional to film area. That is why linear feet belong on their own line. Compare an 8 mil alternative only against the same scope, and don't treat a film-only price as equivalent to a required attached assembly. A cost line describes what is priced; it is not evidence of performance (see reading test reports and the thickness guide). For treatment-plus-film proposals, see C-Bond Secure vs. the BRS system; for coverage, what a warranty covers.

A simple scoring approach

  1. Disqualify proposals that cannot name the product and attachment.
  2. Mark each checklist item complete, partial or missing.
  3. Only then compare totals among proposals that are complete.

Sources

These guides began as AI-assisted drafts from the Shore Tint & More editorial team. Our guides explain product documentation and practical project planning. Manufacturer test claims are linked, and site-specific recommendations require an assessment. Spotted an error? Contact us for corrections.

Related guides