Skip to content
Security FilmGuide

System comparison

Compare by purpose, not by promises.

Choose a project goal to compare construction, attachment requirements and the documentation to request.

Every system is an assembly

Compare products as glass, film, attachment and frame together. For what attachment scopes should cover in a contract, see the attachment project-scope guide and why frame attachment matters.

Conceptual cutaway of a security film assembly: glass, interior film, perimeter attachment and frameA schematic vertical section through one window edge. The frame runs along the top and bottom. The glass sits between them. A thin film layer covers the interior face of the glass, and a perimeter attachment zone connects the film edge to the interior face of the frame at top and bottom. Conceptual and not to scale; not an installation detail or product drawing.EXTERIORINTERIOR1234
  1. Frame. The window or storefront frame and its glazing stops. Its condition and anchorage are part of the assembly.
  2. Glass. The existing glass. Type, thickness and size decide which films and uses the manufacturer allows.
  3. Interior film. Security film applied to the interior glass surface, inside the edge of the visible glass.
  4. Perimeter attachment. Where specified, a manufacturer-approved method that ties the film edge to the frame. Methods are not interchangeable between products.
Conceptual and not to scale. This is not an installation detail, product drawing or certification, and it shows no dimensions or performance. The selected manufacturer's current documentation for the specific film, glass and frame governs the attachment method.
SAFETY · SMASH · FORCED-ENTRY DELAYBALLISTIC RESISTANCEFilm systems, judged by documentationOnly tested, specified assembliesTWO DIFFERENT QUESTIONS — NOT ONE SCALE

4 shown

3M

Scotchshield Ultra S800

Purpose
Clear safety/security film intended to help hold glass fragments together and help delay entry.
Construction (verified)
Clear micro-layered polyester (PET); 8 mil nominal, 9 mil with adhesive, per 3M Technical Specifications, Revision G (Jan 2025).
Attachment
3M requires its Impact Protection Attachment (IPA) sealant for approved break-and-entry applications. Confirm the specified combination for your glass and frame in 3M's documentation.
Spec-review questions
  • Which attachment method and edges are proposed?
  • Is each glass type and size eligible under the guidelines?
  • Data sheet revision referenced?

3M states this film is not bulletproof and not designed to stop intruders.

Documents: 3M Ultra S800 Technical Specifications, Rev. G (Jan 2025) · 3M Security Window Film Installation Guidelines (Jan 2025)

3M

Safety S140 (SH14CLARL)

Purpose
Clear safety/security film for interior glass surfaces; 3M lists shard retention and break-and-entry among its objectives.
Construction (verified)
Clear polyester (PET); 14 mil nominal, per 3M Technical Specifications, Revision D (Jan 2025).
Attachment
Per its current 3M specifications, IPA sealant attachment is required for break-and-entry applications and for spontaneous single-pane tempered breakage concerns.
Spec-review questions
  • Is 3M IPA sealant attachment specified where break-and-entry use is intended?
  • Is each glass type and size eligible?
  • Which attachment method and edges are proposed?

Its specifications state it is not approved for windstorm applications (3.8) or blast mitigation applications (3.9). ASTM methods listed in its references section are not pass results.

Documents: 3M Safety S140 Technical Specifications, Rev. D (Jan 2025) · 3M Security Window Film Installation Guidelines (Jan 2025)

3M

Scotchshield S2400

Purpose
Clear security film within 3M's line aimed at higher forced-entry concerns.
Construction (verified)
Clear polyurethane (not PET); 25 mils with adhesive, per the Apr 2025 technical data sheet.
Attachment
The data sheet requires IPA sealant for windstorm, break-and-entry and explosion-mitigation applications and spontaneous single-pane tempered breakage; the US product page says IPA is required for all applications. Obtain 3M's current specification in writing rather than assuming which applies.
Spec-review questions
  • Which tested assembly supports the stated use?
  • Is the proposed attachment the one referenced?
  • Is 3M IPA sealant attachment included in the scope?

Interior glass surfaces only. The April 2025 data sheet limits explosion applications to commercial and non-educational government facilities, and 3M states the film is not bulletproof and not designed to stop intruders.

Documents: 3M S2400 Technical Data Sheet (Apr 2025) · 3M S2400 product page · 3M Security Window Film Installation Guidelines (Jan 2025)

C-Bond Systems

C-Bond BRS

Purpose
Ballistic-resistant system as described by its manufacturer — a separate category from security film.
Construction (verified)
Multilayer proprietary film used with C-Bond Secure treatment on a specified glass configuration (manufacturer spec sheet).
Attachment
Assembly-specific: glass, film, treatment, frame and size must match the tested configuration.
Spec-review questions
  • Current test report for my glass, frame, size and threat level?
  • Who performed the test and to which standard?
  • What changes if my glass doesn't match?

Manufacturer-reported testing applies to the configuration tested. Existing glass does not become rated by adding film.

Documents: C-Bond BRS manufacturer spec sheet

Thickness basis — not a ranking

ProductPublished figureBasis
Ultra S8008 mil / 9 milNominal film / with adhesive (PET)
Safety S14014 milNominal (PET)
S240025 mil (635 µm) / 24 mil (610 µm)With adhesive, per the data sheet / basis not labeled, per the physical properties bulletin (polyurethane)

These figures use different bases and different materials, so they can't be compared directly. Thickness is not a performance ranking: results depend on the glass, frame, attachment and tested assembly. For other manufacturers' figures and bases, see 8 mil vs 14 mil vs 24 mil, the brand comparison guide and exterior security window film. For C-Bond specifically, see C-Bond Secure vs BRS.

Reading this comparison

S800 and S2400 are documented for interior glass surfaces only. 3M's installation guidelines require 3M Impact Protection Attachment (IPA) sealant for certain approved applications — including break-and-entry, windstorm and explosion uses, and spontaneous breakage concerns with single-pane tempered glass. Separately, 3M's Ultra S800 technical specifications and April 2025 S2400 data sheet limit specified blast-mitigation applications to commercial and non-educational government facilities, which is why this site does not market blast protection for schools or houses of worship. Other mechanical attachment approaches exist, but they are not a substitute where 3M requires IPA.

For a deeper explanation see film vs. ballistic glazing and how to compare proposals.