3M vs Solar Gard vs XPEL vs LLumar: compare the installed system
No brand is universally best. What a facility can compare is the exact product, the glass it goes on, the attachment, and the documents that support the proposed use.
By Shore Tint & More editorial team · · 9 min read
Official sources checked . Procurement pages change; confirm with the agency.
Key takeaways
- A quote that names a brand without a product code leaves the system undefined.
- Manufacturers state thickness on different bases (nominal film, with adhesive, nominal/overall); copy the label exactly.
- A test result belongs to the documented glass, film and attachment configuration, not to every product carrying the brand.
- Solar Gard's Armorcoat and Sentinel documents cited here come from its UK/EU resource index; they are not evidence of US availability, warranty or approval.
Start with the building, not a winner
For a school, congregation or commercial facility, the useful question is not which brand is best. It is which documented installation addresses the project's objective on the glass and framing actually present. Two proposals naming different brands may differ far more in attachment, glass preparation and opening coverage than in the film itself.
This guide does not rank manufacturers, and nothing below says any product failed a test. Where a document we retrieved does not state something, the table says so; that is a question for the bidder, not evidence against the product.
What the manufacturer documentation says
Each row uses only the document linked in that row, as read on November 18, 2026. Figures are copied with their stated basis.
| Product | Stated thickness (basis) | Installation side | Source and limits |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3M Scotchshield Ultra S800 | 8 mil (203 µm) nominal film; 9 mil (230 µm) total with adhesive | Interior glass surfaces only | 3M requires IPA sealant for windstorm, break-and-entry and explosion-mitigation applications; explosion applications are "intended only for applications to commercial and non-educational government facilities". S800 specifications, Rev. G |
| 3M Safety S140 (SH14CLARL) | 14 mil nominal; no separate adhesive-inclusive figure stated | Interior | Section 3.8: "not approved for windstorm applications"; 3.9: "not approved for blast mitigation applications". Listing ASTM methods in section 2 is not a pass result. S140 specifications, Rev. D |
| 3M Scotchshield S2400 | 25 mil (635 µm) with adhesive per the April 2025 data sheet; 24 mil (610 µm) in the April 2025 physical properties bulletin, basis not labeled there | Interior glass surfaces only | The data sheet ties IPA to specific applications, while the US product page says IPA is required "for all applications"; get 3M's current specification in writing. S2400 data sheet |
| XPEL Security Clear 14mil | 14 mil nominal film; S-PSA adhesive; no adhesive-inclusive figure stated | Interior window surface | Lists ANSI Z97.1, CPSC 16 CFR 1201 and UL 972 as PASS; request the reports and the tested assembly. XPEL specification, issued Dec. 17, 2024 |
| LLumar SCL SR PS8 / PS13 | PS8: 0.008 in / 200 µm; PS13: 0.013 in / 325 µm; basis not stated | Not stated on the properties sheet | Clear multi-ply. PS13 is a 13 mil product; do not relabel it 14 mil. LLumar physical properties sheet |
| Solar Gard Armorcoat 14 mil Clear (UK/EU) | 350 µm nominal / 400 µm overall, as labeled | Interior (Armorcoat Clear interior listing) | UK/EU regional document with EN ratings; not evidence of US availability or approval. Armorcoat 10/11/14 mil sheet |
Two cautions follow from the table. First, a thickness column mixes bases: S800's 9 mil includes adhesive, S140's 14 mil is nominal film, and Solar Gard's "overall" figure is its own label, which the sheet does not define as adhesive alone. Second, LLumar's test document library separates safety, forced-entry, blast and windstorm records and names the glass and attachment in report titles — the useful model for any brand: the rating attaches to the configuration tested.
Ask every bidder the same seven questions
- Which exact film and attachment products are included, by product code and document revision?
- What glass type and thickness were observed at each opening, and how were they identified?
- Which published test report supports the proposed use?
- How does the tested assembly (glass, size, frame, attachment) compare with this building's windows and doors?
- What preparation, access, installation, protection and cleanup are included?
- Which warranty, exclusions, inspection and maintenance documents will be delivered?
- Who resolves differences between existing conditions and the approved design?
Have the documented system reviewed for your facility.
The locator shows which listed providers cover your area. Ask each for the exact product, attachment and test documents for your openings.
See listed providers by area →Make quotes comparable
Require an opening schedule showing where each proposed system goes, and separate optional work from the base scope. When proposals use different attachment approaches, products or areas, ask for written clarification rather than normalizing them yourself. A lower total can reflect a different scope rather than a better price for the same work. The bid scope template and proposal comparison guide give the line items; why frame attachment matters explains the edge.
What a brand comparison cannot establish
A brand chart is not a safety assessment or an approval for a building. Keep claims tied to the supplied documents and have the responsible design or security professional review the selected assembly. This site is published by Shore Tint & More, an installer; that commercial relationship is disclosed and does not change the evidence standard applied to any manufacturer's documents. Film is not bulletproof, and no product here is presented as stopping intruders.
The systems page compares 3M products by purpose; thickness is covered in 8 mil vs 14 mil vs 24 mil and installation side in exterior security window film.
Frequently asked questions
Which security film brand is best?
None is universally best. Compare the documented system for your glass, frame and objective.
Is a 14 mil XPEL film the same as 3M S140?
Both list 14 mil nominal, but construction, adhesive and tested configurations differ. A shared number does not establish equivalence.
Can we specify a Solar Gard Sentinel or Armorcoat product we found online?
The documents cited are from Solar Gard's UK/EU index. Confirm US availability, warranty and documentation with the manufacturer first.
Sources
- 3M Ultra S800 Technical Specifications, Rev. G (Jan 2025)
- 3M Safety S140 Technical Specifications, Rev. D (Jan 2025)
- 3M S2400 Technical Data Sheet (Apr 2025)
- 3M S2400 Physical Properties bulletin, Rev. A (Apr 2025)
- 3M S2400 product page
- XPEL Security Clear 14mil specification (issued Dec. 17, 2024)
- XPEL product specifications library
- LLumar safety and security film physical properties
- LLumar safety film test documents
- Solar Gard UK/EU resource index
- Solar Gard Armorcoat 10, 11 & 14 Mil Clear (UK/EU sheet)
These guides began as AI-assisted drafts from the Shore Tint & More editorial team. Our guides explain product documentation and practical project planning. Manufacturer test claims are linked, and site-specific recommendations require an assessment. Spotted an error? Contact us for corrections.